We join Sky Wishes and Star Catcher on Butterfly Island where Sky Wishes, wishes the fun would never end. They decide the pair wants each other to meet each other’s set of friends. Sky Wishes decides to throw a party in Ponyville where Star Catcher’s shy Pegasus pony friends, can meet her earth pony friends. The earth ponies find it hard to believe there are such ponies as Pegasus ponies but go along with the party anyways, while Star Catcher convinces the Pegasus ponies to go to the party.