S1, E13: Henry and Jo's murder investigation of an ex-con, who is being framed for a jewelry store heist, reveals a special connection between the victim and Jo's late husband, Sean (guest star Andy Karl – Joyful Noise), who was an assistant district attorney. Jo's evocative memories reflect her warm and wonderful relationship with Sean, which become almost too painful for her to bear. Flashbacks trace Henry's life to 1816 London where he ends up in jail. Incredibly, his cell mate is a priest (Tony® Award winner Roger Rees – Cheers, The West Wing) who gives Henry a second chance at life. Meanwhile, Abe attempts to snare a thief whom he believes walked off with a "priceless" antique from his store, and Henry is there to comfort Jo in her time of distress. Guest star Shane McRae (The Following) appears as Detective Hugh Dunn.