S3, E11: Everyone is back from Winter Break, and the ZBZ girls are dealing with the guilt of possibly having burned down the Gamma Psi house. In hopes of helping them out, Casey volunteers to assist in planning a Fairytale Ball to raise money to rebuild their house. Cappie tries to be a great boyfriend by lending a hand but seems to keep disappointing Casey, causing her not to trust him enough to reveal her secret. When the fire department declares the fire was indeed caused by a candle left lit (one that Rebecca lit while they were inside) the girls freak out since Ashleigh still has the clipboard they snuck in to steal which is now evidence against them. They decide the best thing to do is bury the evidence – literally. In the meantime, Cappie is having a hard time getting over Wade, Jeremy and Ferret being expelled over the prank with OX. When Rusty tries to take over Wade’s position as pledge educator, Cappie doesn’t have his back as much as usual since he doesn’t think anyone will live up to the job Wade did in the past. While trying to tame the pledges, Rusty learns that he beat Dale (who had already hired interns!) out for the engineering grant which causes the tension between them to continue. Over at OX, Calvin is annoyed when he learns Grant didn’t come out to his parents over the break so they have to wait to come out to the house as a couple. Evan and Rebecca try to figure out how to proceed in their friendship after they hooked up before Winter Break.