S1, E4: Tessa returns from their overnight meeting to find that someone has been in their home...and stolen the tapes. As they attempt to come to terms with their new reality, Betsy drops in for afternoon tea and shares unsettling information that shifts the entire narrative around Amelia’s disappearance. Tessa begins to suspect that their privacy has been compromised in more ways than one, even as more bizarre disturbances emerge from the basement. What began as a search for answers has quickly become a descent into something far deeper.