S3, E13: Casey and Ashleigh miss each other now that Casey spends most of her nights at Cappie's place. Casey's solution is for Ashleigh to start dating Beaver! On a terrible double date, the KT's extend Casey and Ashleigh an offer to play with ZBZ in the upcoming softball tournament for blue ribbon points. Ashleigh stalls to answer until the Omega Chi's extend an offer and the ZBZ's (minus Casey) whole heartedly accept. Since Gamma Psi assumed the Omega Chi was going to extend them an offer, they choose KT to ruffle the feathers of ZBZ. On the field, tensions are high, and come to a head when Grant freaks out because he's getting teased for coming out of the closet. Calvin tells him to let it go but Grant finds an unlikely supporter in Rusty who actually has his back in the argument that ensues. At the game winning pitch, Casey is forced to choose between her allegiance to ZBZ and Cappie, but her competitive side helps her choose ZBZ. Cappie is supportive but Casey sees that maneuvering this relationship may not be easy.