시즌 3, 에피소드 1: It’s the day after the End of the World party which has changed some people’s lives dramatically. Max has gone back to England since Casey broke his heart, so Rusty has no one to talk to about his choice to go to the party over finishing his Chemistry project. He tries to get into the lab but finds it locked. Jordan implores Casey to help Rusty who is now failing the Honors Program. Casey, still hurt from her encounter with Cappie at the party, agrees to take charge and help her brother. When they try to get into the lab, Cappie shows up also intending to help Rusty. The three awkwardly get the project done but not without confronting each other about what really happened the night before and what it means for Casey and Cappie. Rebecca is mysterious about hooking up with a guy at the previous night’s party, and offers to pay Evan if he will pretend to be that guy. The Omega Chi’s throw a Dead Man’s party to celebrate the start of the Gotcha! Game, and Evan has to endure being Rebecca’s new boyfriend until she shocks everyone with a “breakup”. Calvin thinks he slept with Grant, but finds out they just kissed while Dale slept with Sheila and is extremely upset about losing his virginity. When Casey and Cappie have a moment on campus where she shoots him as part of Gotcha!, he flashes back to the End of the World party when Evan talks him out of chasing after Casey explaining they’re just not right for her.