This Is Your Nine Lives

S1, E29: It's Salem's birthday and he's used to getting the lavish gifts. Sabrina thinks her homemade gift sucks so she time travels to get him a unique gift... well-wishes from all his buddies from the old days. Along the way, Sabrina realizes that Salem has hurt more people than he's helped. Sabrina & Co. are captured by the pirate John Lefoot, so he can use Sabrina's power for his own greediness. Sabrina must escape with herself and her friends in once piece! She learns that when giving a gift, it's the thought that counts.