When James proposes to his college sweetheart Melissa it sends their recently broken-up best friends, Ben and Rachel, on a tailspin of internet dates. However, when Ben and Rachel tell the newly engaged couple about their dating app escapades it only makes James and Melissa begin to doubt their own relationship and wonder whether they're missing out on all the fun. To quell their curiosity and see what all the fuss is about Melissa and James decide to make Tinder profiles together late one night. Soon, a fun joke turns sour when long held insecurities and tensions begin to surface in this ensemble comedy that explores love and dating in the digital age.