Born in Boulder, Colorado and raised in Denver, Lynch initially became drawn to acting while in high school. He began appearing in school plays, and eventually went on to study theatre at the Catholic University of America in Washington, D.C. After earning his B.F.A. from the University in 1986, Lynch turned all of his focus to the stage. He joined the Guthrie Theater Acting Company in Minnesota and started appearing in local productions of Shakespeare and Chekov's timeless works. By the late '80s, Lynch was touring the country as a stage actor. Eventually, however, Lynch yearned for something more, and started auditioning for film and TV roles. His first on-screen performance came in 1993, when he landed a small part as a burly moving man in the old-timer comedy "Grumpy Old Men." More roles followed, including a small part as military officer in the 1995 made-for-TV-movie, "In the Line of Duty: Hunt for Justice," before his breakout performance in 1996's "Fargo." Lynch drew unanimous acclaim for his role as a sensitive husband with an artistic side in the Coen Brothers' modern take on the crime thriller. That same year, Lynch appeared in two additional Minnesota-set films - "Beautiful Girls" and "Feeling Minnesota" - in addition to making guest appearances on "Frasier" (NBC 1993-2004) and "Murder One" (ABC 1995-97). Lynch's career continued to rise throughout the remainder of the '90s, most notably after he started appearing as Drew Carey's husky, cross-dressing brother Steve on "The Drew Carey Show." A role as a police sheriff in the 2003 horror film "Gothika," caught the eye of director David Fincher, who proceeded to cast Lynch in his 2007 crime-biopic "Zodiac." Working with some of the film community's most celebrated directors proved to be a pattern for Lynch, and over the next few years he appeared in films made by Clint Eastwood ("Gran Torino," 2008) and Martin Scorsese ("Shutter Island," 2010), as well in Mark Ruffalo's 2010 directorial debut, "Sympathy for Delicious." In 2011 Lynch landed a recurring role on the medical drama "Body of Proof" (ABC 2011-2013), playing a detective. However, the network cancelled the show in May 2013 due to low ratings. Undeterred, Lynch landed a recurring part on another medical drama, NBC's "Do No Harm" (2013), that same year. However, that show was also cancelled because of low viewership. Following a story arc on 1980s-set espionage drama "The Americans" (FX 2013-), Lynch scored a memorable role as the horrifying Twisty the Clown on the fourth season of the anthology series "American Horror Story" (FX 2011-).