Detective Benson is wrapping up a suspect interrogation when she gets a mysterious flier that shows the location of Jeffrey Ronsen's remains. Jeffrey was seven in 1980 when he disappeared, and the prime suspect in the case, Lucas Biggs (John Savage), is on death row for a different murder in Virginia, and is a week away from execution. They dig up the remains and at the funeral start inspecting the guests. Deacon Brinn (Terry Serpico) is there with his wife and son - Deacon was thirteen, and babysitting Jeffrey the night he disappeared. Avery Shaw (Michael Shannon), Jeffrey's former teammate, also arrives and is very shaken up.