When Mark tries to play Cupid between Lucas and a pretty young stranger who arrives in North Fork, the girl's two older brothers accuse him of trifling with her affections and challenge him to fight them both.
Bat heads to the town of Trinidad to investigate a newly elected sheriff who used Bat's name to land the job.
Bat Masterson baits a trap with more than $15,000, in order to catch cattle thieves preying on the herd of his friend Hugh Blaine.
Bat has a claim on saloon owner Walker Hayes for a gambling debt and is determined to make an honest man of him.