Jack (Alec Baldwin) feels unworthy of his latest award and attempts to redeem himself by taking on the writers in a strategic board game. Liz (Tina Fey) believes she’s cursed on St. Patrick’s Day when her ex-boyfriend Dennis (guest star Dean Winters) shows up to derail her relationship with Criss (guest star James Marsden). Meanwhile, Hazel (guest star Kristen Schaal) struggles to keep the peace between Tracy (Tracy Morgan) and Jenna (Jane Krakowski).
After an encounter with Dennis Duffy, Liz and Criss decide to take drastic measures to start a family. As Liz looks toward the future, Jack and Jenna evaluate their own self-worth, and Tracy laments a shocking medical diagnosis.
Piper must face the aftermath of her battle with Pennsatucky.