Stacey and Keith return homes from the police station only to find their daughter Day is gone. Keith questions Stacey about their daughter's whereabouts; Stacey has a mental issue that causes her to forget things. Tony teams up with Lisa to find Day.

Tony brings Day home and questions Stacey about her past with Keith and Karen. Stacey tells Tony, Karen, and Keith dated back in High School. Tony tells Stacey about this boy, Kevin, claiming to be Day's brother.

Tony returns to the site where she and Stacey buried Karen, only to find out from a phone call that Karen is not dead. Tony and Stacey try to figure out with help from Lisa who is helping Karen and if it could be Zeke, the detective.