Mary and Joseph struggle with telling Jesus who his real father is. Meanwhile, Jesus is confused by the mysterious creatures he keeps creating.

After being fired from his step-father's store, Jesus takes a job at Pontius Pilate's restaurant. Pilate wants Jesus to feed thousands through a miracle Jesus performs with couscous.

Joseph has a dream that an angel tells him it's okay to reach outside of his marriage. When the angel incarnates as a beautiful seductress, it causes multiple problems for Jesus, Mary, and Joseph.

Joseph tires of paying the way for his step-son and asks Pontius Pilate to help him sue for child support. But as the trial approaches, strange things keep happening to Joseph.