An aspiring villain longs to join the Evil League of Evil and win the girl of his dreams, but his arch nemesis, Capt. Hammer, thwarts him at every turn.

Disheartened by the burgeoning romance of Penny and Capt. Hammer, Horrible pursues his evil plans.

Capt. Hammer is honored with a statue for his latest good deed, but Horrible has other plans for his nemesis.