Captain Hook and Mr. Smee sneak around Pirate Island trying to find the Pirate's hideout. Jake's crew find a beautiful shell and Hook steals it for his collection.

Jake and the crew find Hook's hat washed up on the beach and try to return it to him. Hook snatches Jake's guitar and throws it into Belch Mountain because he's sick of listening to it.

Hook takes off with Jake's skateboard, so Jake and the crew chase after him to retrieve it. Hook wants Izzy's fun and sparkly Hipster Twister Hoop and sends the Never Bird to steal it.

Hook spies the healthy snacks Cubby's prepared for Jake's crew and steals them. Izzy accidentally sprinkles pixie dust on on the crew's basketball, making it fly out of the hideout and into Hook's hands.

Hook's annoyed it's windy, until he sees the pirates having fun with kites and steals them. Hook tries to steal Bucky, Jake's pirate ship, not realising Bucky is alive.

Jake, Izzy and Cubby throw a Happy Bird-Day party for Skully, but Captain Hook steals all of the presents. Izzy finds a boomerang, but Captain Hook steals it, thinking it's a magic stick.