Town namesake Nathan Rutherford and his best friend Reagan Wells find themselves at a crossroads when their sleepy town gets an unexpected wake-up call.

Nathan seeks advice from his old college history professor; Reagan agrees to join Terry as he tries to win over members of their Tribal Council.

Nathan leaves Rutherford Falls and heads to his brother Duz's home, eager to reconnect with his family; Reagan is put in charge of the museum with Bobbie's help.

Terry reflects on his family and career during an interview with Josh; Nathan attempts to smooth things over in his own way.

Nathan and Reagan serve as judges in the town's annual History Fair; Terry Thomas and Mayor Deirdre attempt to find common ground.

Nathan seeks powerful allies to help with his legal difficulties; Reagan turns to the community to solicit donations for her cultural centre.