A celebratory Mother's Day for the Baxter family's matriarch, Elizabeth, is disrupted when one of her daughters, Kari, discovers a shocking revelation about her husband, Tim.

When Kari returns to her parents' home, she discovers that her first love, Ryan, has also returned to town; Tim aims to strengthen his bond with Angela.

The Baxter family navigates life's highs and lows, both with and without God.

Kari's pregnancy revelation to Tim leaves Angela frustrated over his stalled divorce; Dirk's obsession with Angela persists; Kari enjoys a day with Ryan; John offers a hopeful message for Elizabeth and their family.

Struggling with alcoholism, Tim's life spirals downward; Luke invites Reagan over for a pool date at the Baxter family home; Ashley unexpectedly runs into an old high school crush; Kari seeks marital advice from her mother.

Kari and Tim work on mending their marriage; Luke and Reagan's courtship continues; Ryan faces a coaching opportunity that requires him to leave Kari; Elizabeth reunites with Ashley's friend, who is linked to her traumatic past.