Amber meets Brandon online and quickly falls for him, but when strange events and a secretive ex-wife Athena raise red flags, she digs deeper; she uncovers a trail of lies, restraining orders and other women asking the same question: who is Brandon?

Amber and Athena launch a podcast to expose Brandon's lies, but when more victims come forward and a $400,000 embezzlement charge surfaces, Brandon disappears after a police chase; they now fear the story isn't over and the danger isn't either.

Amber and Athena warn Brandon's new girlfriend, Rachel, but when she ends things, the danger escalates; Brandon breaks in, attacks and is caught with disturbing items in his car; the entire assault is caught on camera.