Newly engaged Jennifer and Adam start to backpedal when they hear their long-married friends argue over a bicycle.

Jeff wants to stay on Audrey's good side to ensure that he gets his yearly birthday deal; Russell tries to figure out what Jeff's birthday gift really is.

Audrey bets that Jeff cannot get a younger woman's phone number; Jennifer wants to get rid of their bed because Adam bought it with an ex-girlfriend.

Audrey is upset when Jeff seems more interested in the outcome of a New York Knicks game than in her news about a big promotion; Adam and Jennifer argue over how they are spending their money.

A chance meeting with an old flame prompts Russell to right a previous wrong.

Jeff helps Jennifer lift her heavy sofa, but he soon feels guilty.