Big Littles & Jumbo Shrimp

S2, E14: Troubled by the recent discovery that Andy (Jesse McCartney) hooked up with Jordan (Johanna Braddy), Rusty (Jacob Zachar) is hesitant to take Andy on as his little brother. Will Rusty be able to get past the budding relationship to become the big brother Cappie (Scott Michael Foster) has been to him? When Cappie hears of Rusty's reluctance, he takes Rusty aside to remind him that he brought Andy as a pledge to the fraternity and it is his responsibility to be the best Big Brother that Rusty can be for him. Meanwhile, when Evan's (Jake McDorman) real-life brother, Patrick (Robert Hoffman), comes for a visit, their celebration at Dobler's is interrupted by Cappie and the three end up reminiscing about their old camp days. But later Patrick shocks and disappoints Evan by asking for money. Frustrated by his brother's actions, Evan takes it out on Frannie. When Casey (Spencer Grammer) and Rebecca (Dilshad Vadsaria) believe that the thief responsible for stealing the ZBZ food supply is Fisher (Andrew J. West), they can't figure out why Ashleigh (Amber Stevens) won't accept it. But when they dig a little further, Ashleigh reveals the delicious truth.