Michael Lee Kimel

At a fraternity costume party, Damon takes advantage of the wild scene to give Elena a lesson in choosing a victim. Rebekah fails to buy Matt's forgiveness, and is later intrigued by unexpected news from Klaus.

Stefan and Klaus form an uneasy alliance to try and put an end to the trouble Connor has caused. When Connor takes Jeremy, Matt and April hostage, Stefan and Damon have a serious disagreement about the best course of action, and Elena is again caught between the two brothers and Caroline is surprised to find Hayley at the Lockwood mansion.

Fallon and Cristal both compete for the cover of a magazine. Meanwhile, Steven's ex returns. Sammy Jo and Anders discover an unlikely connection.