Be careful what you wish for! This is what three couples must remember as they venture to Fantasy Island. The first couple want to meet the daughter they gave up for adoption 12 years ago. In the second story, a business woman visits the island under false pretenses, thinking she is there for a business meeting only to have one of her employees confess his undying love for her. In the final story, a young wife suffers amnesia caused by a mysterious incident that occurred four years ago.

A magician wants to perform the `ultimate escape'. Two high-school friends become true-life Cinderellas.

Fred and Joan Wade gamble everything they own on their dream of building a grand resort hotel. Nondescript Chuck Huffman wants to be ultra-attractive to every woman who sees him.

In `The Prince', a handsome prince comes to Fantasy Island to be a nobody, and in `The Sheriff': a police officer seeks vengeance against his partner's killers.

Mr Rourke's guests arrive on Fantasy Island to fulfil their dreams. Amnesiac Jane Howell discovers her real identity through Voodoo and the Kellino children reunite their parents.

A well-known call girl wants to escape her old life and find true love. A race-car driver wants to relive a crash to end his nightmares of it.