After having a strange dream, Madoka Kaname is surprised to find that a girl from her dream enrolls at her school the next day.

Madoka and Sayaka lose their way in a mysterious place, and find themselves faced with a difficult situation. Mami Tomoe, a magical girl, rescues them before inviting them to her room.

Madoka and Sayaka are becoming familiar with Mami's witch hunting, but they have yet to decide what they want to use their wishes for.

Madoka is in despair over Mami's death. Sayaka and Madoka realise the full extent of what it means to be part of the magical world, and abandon their quest to become magical girls.

Now that her wish has come true by signing Kyubey's contract, Sayaka's mind is clear and she doesn't seem to have any regrets.

Kyubey informs Sayaka that Madoka could become a magical girl, but Sayaka is against the idea and doesn't want Madoka to get involved.