While attending a comedy party, Julie and Billy discover an opportunity to participate in an Atheist Podcast led by a guy name Sonny. Meanwhile, Marilyn works towards putting on a play and insists that Julie comes to support her. Billy, on the other hand, must decide if he wants to stay with the "too nice" Carl, or give Terrance, the random guy in the dog park, a chance. But when the podcast takes off successfully, Julie and Billy find themselves pushing towards making connections with NPR despite Arthur’s dislike. When the podcast and Terrance fall through, Billy and Julie agree not to settle in the future for what’s easy.