Diagnosis Murder · S6, E12
Trapped in Paradise
When resident Paul Brewer is killed, it's the second murder in a month at the exclusive gated community, Hillview Estates. As there are no leads on the killer, Steve goes undercover as community resident, Dr. Steve Brewer. Surprisingly, Steve finds a "Mrs. Brewer' waiting for him. "Mrs. Brewer' is actually Shelby Turner, a pesky reporter from a rag magazine who has been conducting her own unofficial stake-out. The first evening in their new home, Shelby throws a dinner party for the community and collects fingerprints off the silverware of all the guests. Shockingly, Amanda's fingerprint analysis reveals that all the guests at the dinner party are deceased! Back at Hillview, another resident dies when he falls off a ladder and breaks his neck. Amanda's autopsy report shows nothing unusual except for traces of the same thyroid replacement drug in Harris' body that was also found in Paul Brewer's body.