Rachel is a wholesome virgin from Minnesota who ended her relationship with Fabian when she discovered he had cheated on her. Fabian is guilt ridden and desperate to win Rachel back, although she may no longer be the wholesome girl he once knew.

When Matt and Sunnie were dating, he was jealous of her burgeoning career and continuously felt passed over when she went off on long business trips. However, Matt has kept a secret that has been weighing on him for the past three years, and Sunnie has a secret that's even more shocking than Matt's revelation.

Rob and Shivonne had been an item for seven years on and off, but most recently they have been off. Rob is finally ready to settle down and ask Shivonne to move to New York City and live with him. However, Shivonne also has some secrets that she'd like to tell Rob.

After Melicka was ghosted by her boyfriend Tahir, she was left confused and heartbroken. She wants answers from Tahir so she can finally move on. But Tahir has a secret that will explain his disappearance and change everything for their relationship.

When Abby and Keith were dating, Abby was undoubtedly the alpha. Now, Abby wants Keith back and is aware that she has some apologizing to do for treating him like a doormat when they were together. But things have changed for Keith, who is determined to not get sucked back into her manipulative ways.

Conrad has two simple questions: did Schedel cheat, and can he have a piece of his heart back? Schedel has answers, but like him, they are far from simple. Can Conrad forgive his eccentric and emotionally guarded ex, and get back the piece of his heart that Schedel still holds?