Skyler says she’s been wronged by none other than the Toothfairy herself, and so she’s taking her to court to get the tooth cash she deserves. So imagine her and Judge Puppet’s surprise when the toothfairy’s intern Bruce shows up instead!

Hayden is taking his little brother Gael to court because he won’t stop copying him. Or he won’t stop copying him. Who won’t stop copying who? It’s up to Judge Puppet to figure out who the real copy cat is and dole out a double dose of justice.

Jack’s upset because his friend Olivia froze him in a game of tag and just left him that way. For like three days! But justice stops for nobody in Judge Puppet’s court - and he’s ready to figure out how to finally thaw their cold, cold war.

Evan and Mikaela are going to court to fight over custody of their beloved Derek. The only problem is Derek is a burrito. Will this wrap flap tear Evan and Mikaela apart? Or will everyone tear Derek apart and eat him for lunch? Only Judge Puppet knows for sure.

Leah claims she has been cheated by Roen, a popular playground doctor who sold her an ineffective cooties shot. Leah is sure she has cooties now, and is taking Roen to court to get back the money she paid. Lucky for her, Judge Puppet has armed himself with a family-sized hand santizer dispenser filled with truth and justice.

Breelyn is taking Anaya to court for filling her party piñata with parmesan cheese. Anaya says she did it on accident due to a blindfold blunder. Is Anaya telling the truth, or will she be caught in a cheesy lie? Judge Puppet alone can serve up some cheesy justice on a fancy platter.