Ex-convict John Cole shows up at Sherman Ranch with the wounded Marshal Briggs and stirs up old memories for Slim Sherman.

Jess Harper is on his way home to Laramie and gets more than he bargained for when he's forced to stop and rest his lame horse at Ma Tolliver's.

Slim Sherman and Daisy Cooper are visiting Laramie but soon become entangled in a murder mystery that may involve Slim's boss, Allen Winter.

Frank Mannus arrives in Laramie but his reputation got there first. Billy O'Neil remembers how Mannus treated his sister Abbey and intends to kill Mannus for it.

Lars Carlson has sent for a mail-order bride, but she doesn't show up. Dancehall girl Zoie Carter thinks marriage will make her respectable so she decides to take her place.

Slim, Daisy and Mike are on their way home when the encounter Kathy Frances, a little girl whose mother has fallen into a well. Slim is about to send Daisy for help when three robbers show up.