In the series premiere, Steve Sullivan (series star STEVE BYRNE) returns home to Pittsburgh to celebrate his father, Jack Sullivan's birthday (series star DAN LAURIA). He quickly learns that Jack is retiring and selling the family bar Sullivan & Son. Steve contemplates leaving his New York corporate life behind to buy the bar from his parents.

After getting into an argument with his Korean mother Ok Cha (series star JODI LONG), Steve decides to set boundaries with his parents now that he is in charge. But when the health inspector shows up, his newfound leadership is tested and his troubles with the bar translate into some unexpected jail time. Meanwhile, Owen (series star OWEN BENJAMIN) suddenly finds a job and new meaning in life, but it seems too good to be true.

Steve hosts a party for the 50th year of Sullivan & Son. Owen and Carol act as each others' wingmen. Jack and Ok Cha (series star Jodi Long) argue about old lies. Steve and Melanie (series star Valerie Azlynn) uncover a secret about the origins of the bar.

During the annual 'Father and Son Darts Tournament,' Owen decides he wants to search his real dad as Jack works out his abandonment issues with Steve. And Hank and Carol try to hide an old secret.

In the dramatic season one finale, Christopher and Elena begin to learn that not everyone is as they appear to be. Long-buried secrets are revealed as the past rears its ugly head. A thief threatens Steve and Melanie's personal and professional relationships. Owen and Ahmed (guest star AHMED AHMED) enter an "offbeat" business. Carol and Hank share new and old ways to go on dates.

Owen and Carol bring a new act to the bar, while Steve and Melanie uncover middle school mysteries.