James discusses a plan with dire consequences and fears his legacy will be that of a killer. Jenny makes a deal and contemplates buying a gun. Willem must protect someone in danger and starts to spy on his target. Mrs. Tyler acknowledges that innocent people will get hurt as a result of her actions. Melody is desperate for money and Allen is caught in a lie. Sister Carmel desperately wants to hear God again.

Doris starts to ask questions and develops a theory. Allen completes his task but realizes he made the wrong deal. Sister Carmel is taken aback by her task, and Willem is surprised when he meets the girl of his dreams. Melody starts to see results while Mrs. Tyler has doubts about finishing what she started. Jenny obtains a gun and loves the rush. Someone is on to James.

Jenny asks if she can recruit an accomplice. Mrs. Tyler in conflicted about proceeding while Allen's true motives are revealed. Melody grows closer to Ron but is concerned by his behavior. Sister Carmel tries to come to terms with her lies. Willem is heralded as a hero but his paranoia grows. James has trouble holding up his end of the deal. Doris wants someone to listen but fails to get any answers.

Sister Carmel meets someone and sneaks around. The kidnapper's identity is revealed and James tracks him down. Richard makes his first deal and Jenny wants to help. Allen regrets what he's done and contemplates how to make things right. Mrs. Tyler gets what she wants and Doris shares an intimate detail. Melody uncovers disturbing information and goes to the police.

Allen fears for his son's safety and comes to terms with his own wrongdoing. Richard makes a new deal and gets what he wants. Willem takes matters into his own hands. Two people are killed. Sister Carmel shares some news and Doris learns a single mysterious fact. Gerald asks for the unthinkable.

The Man sets up shop in another diner. Here new clients, and some familiar ones, make deals with The Man. They choose to complete one task and report to The Man about their progress in exchange for one desire being fulfilled.

The Man shows signs of change when Doris, the inquisitive waitress from the first diner, appears in his new booth of choice. Meanwhile, The Man’s customers report on their progress with their tasks. Some have made great strides, while others are still trying to figure out what it is that they really want.

The Man’s patrons encounter complications with their tasks. Some struggle with issues of faith, others with their sense of morality. But many start to see evidence that the deeds they’re performing are bringing them closer to what they covet.

As the end of the tasks approaches, the customers find more resistance standing between them and their tasks than they were expecting. The Man reports on his progress to Doris, and it becomes clear that he’s more comfortable asking the questions than answering them.

The tasks that people have completed come to fruition in surprising ways and The Man’s business with Doris is not yet finished.