Natalee Holloway disappears from Aruba in May 2005, and her father Dave never stops looking for her; he receives a new lead that could be the key to solving the 12-year-old mystery, but he has suspicions about the source.

Pursuing a lead that may shed light on his daughter's disappearance, Dave Holloway and a team of investigators dive into a covert operation. The goal: obtain a taped confession, and evidence that could convict his daughter's killer.

Tensions are high as the sting operation in New Orleans continues. The investigative team is running out of time to obtain the necessary information from the co-conspirator regarding his involvement in the Natalee Holloway case.

TJ and his team head to Aruba to begin phase two of their investigation - attempting to obtain DNA evidence from Natalee's alleged burial site. Dave must convince his informant to go the extra mile to ensure the next step of their investigation

TJ races to the location that the co-conspirator claims is where he dug up Natalee's remains in 2010. Working with the Aruban authorities, they search for DNA that could lead to convicting those involved in Natalee's disappearance.

After two years following this lead, the investigators finally have evidence in hand that could answer the 12 year old mystery of what happened to Natalee Holloway.