In 2014 gunshots are reported in the Rogers home. Maria Edwards who phoned 9-11 refuses to give her statement without a lawyer present. Doctors and detectives work to piece together the events led up to what looks like an attempted murder suicide.

On March 21st 2011, a fire burned down a parsonage behind a church and a Pastor; David Allen lost his wife Paula. Once the fire had settled a fire marshal investigated the site and discovered that there was more to the story than an accidental fire.

March 23, 2006, a police deputy discovers an abandoned car in Gig Harbor, Washington. Inside the trunk, he finds a dead body that will send a quiet family neighborhood reeling from a barrage of lies.

Karla leaves her home one night and never returns. The next day, her husband calls the police to file a missing person report. When the police uncover a treasure trove of hidden secrets, they have to decide who is telling the truth and who is lying.

August 7, 2000, Casey Tiner and her boyfriend TJ Steele disappear. At first, people believe they ran away. But as time passes and the young couple never reappear, their families and the police realize someone is lying.

Three months after high school sweethearts, Lisa and Jimmy Moore, end their marriage, Lisa disappears. Fearing the worst, her family file a missing person report, but the police have no leads, no witnesses, but they do know that someone is lying.