Small Town Secrets

Denise Pflum leaves home in rural Indiana to look for her purse in 1986 and is never seen again. The sheriff's department takes a fresh look at the case, and her ex.

Two cousins allegedly confess multiple times to killing Denise, but they've never been arrested, and police say one of them hasn't even been questioned.

While in custody, Denise's ex-boyfriend confesses to killing her. When he dies before the case can go to trial, Connersville is left with more questions than answers.