This time Ryder, Ben, and James head to the Colorado Rockies to inspect claims of animal mutilations and reports of abductions. These instances take place San Luis Valley, a town with decades of history involving UFO sightings. Residents are eager to share their encounters with the team - everything from hovering green lights to speeding saucers. After spotting a few questionable lights in the night sky, Ryder, Ben, and James meet with local ranchers to learn further about the animal mutilations. They also meet a man who claims he was abducted by aliens.