Comedy Bang! Bang!

Reggie shares the song he wrote for Scott. Guy Benoit (Thomas Lennon) recommends wine throughout the show. Scott plays a game called "Tsk Tsk, Attaboy!" in which people on the street are presented with different scenarios (a man dropping his wallet or a crying baby locked inside a car) to see how they react. Scott and Zach Galifianakis discuss their favorite ways to laugh. Zach imagines what it would be like if dogs could talk. Danny Mahoney (Andrew Daly) stops by to promote his new business in which he comes to your party and acts as the "life of the party." Scott feeds his parking meter. Chet Barnsider (Will Forte) describes how he landed a plane on a mall. The guests play a round of "What's in the Box?"

The episode is dedicated to Carl Langer, a crew member who died during the filming of the episode (though he shows up throughout the show in increasingly dangerous situations). Reggie and Scott describe the strange dreams they had about each other. Scott and Amy Poehler discuss her behavioral issues and the MAD Magazine parody of Parks and Recreation. Don Dimello (Andrew Daly) stops by to discuss his upcoming production of "Pinocchio." Scott goes to pick up his dry cleaning while Mr. Doublebutt (David Koechner) fills in as substitute host. Reggie premieres the trailer for his film "A Womb of One's Own," in which he plays an inattentive father who wishes he had never been born and then finds himself back in his mother's womb. The guests play a round of "What's the Song Title?" As the credits play, we find out how Carl died during filming.

Scott answers questions from Peter the Meter Reader (Neil Campbell). Scott tries to surprise a lucky viewer by visiting them at their home, but is beaten to it by Andy Richter. Jon Hamm describes an unusual day in his life. Scott embarrasses Jon by playing a clip from early in his career. Scott directs a scene in which Jon describes how he and Scott met. Phineas MacEnchee (Eddie Pepitone) is named Employee of the Week. Spanish radio personality El Chupacabra (Nick Kroll) stops by, does some impressions, and gives his slogans for Craigslist and The View. Brett Gelman tries to help a dog beat murder charges. Francis "Mr. Bicycle" Domingo (Leo Allen) discusses his ability to eat bicycles. Scott gives his opinions on Woody Allen, The Beatles, and roller coasters in the segment "Maybe It's Just Me But For Me."

Scott and Reggie check the "watermelon cam," showing the aftermath of throwing watermelons off of the roof. Scott tries to surprise a fan with a home visit but when she's not home he tries to find her in the style of Law and Order. Michael Cera sit downs for an interview where he discusses his birth and the upcoming Angry Birds movie. Scott dies from a caffeine overdose and goes to Hell. Sir Couchly (the couch) complains about his job. Cake Boss (Paul F. Tompkins) stops by and describes how he was bitten by a cake bug and was given the gift of second sight. Reggie is upset by the amount of product placement in the show. Kid scientist Arlo Nadon demonstrates a chemical reaction. The guests play a round of "Which Came First?" Scott plays a highlight reel from the show and Michael Cera meets his demise.

Host Scott Aukerman interviews Seth Rogen about his recent vacation. Scott uses his psychic powers to listen in on people's most private thoughts. The world's top child bird caller visits and performs. Bandleader Reggie Watts interrupts the show to paint a portrait of Scott. Scott leads everyone in the game "What's Their Ailment?"

Host Scott Aukerman welcomes guest Paul Rudd, and discovers they both have a love of mime. The inventor of the adorable Crowpoke robot attempts to repair it when it breaks down. Huell Howser becomes fascinated by Scott, bandleader Reggie Watts, and everything else. A man who should be dead tells the harrowing tale of how he lost his arm. Scott leads his guests in the game "Ring it or Ding It".