Due to the power surge that Mary and Otto caused in bringing Pritchard back to life, two notorious murderers escape from prison. Still determined that this is his city to protect, Pritchard goes on the hunt for them, and Mary – who believes she’s partially responsible for the fugitives’ escape – offers assistance. Meanwhile, in order to win Duval’s trust, Pritchard tells him they’re half-brothers.

A case from the past comes back into play as Pritchard and Duval investigate a series of murders involving young prodigies. As the investigation unravels, Duval comes to terms with the possibility that Pritchard could be his father reincarnated. Meanwhile, Pritchard manages to become a confidential informant for the FBI.

Pritchard and Duval must stop a killer who mutilates and disfigures his victims. Meanwhile, as Pritchard and Mary grow increasingly close to one another, Otto feels resentment and wants to find a new donor.