Timmy gets a quick lesson in "be careful what you wish for" when he wishes to be a grown-up. Rather than becoming the strapping, muscular, older Timmy of his dreams, he turns into a short, bald, hairy-backed, middle-aged man! / The Godparents create a video game where players can go inside and Chester and A.J. accidentally enter the game!

Timmy tries to out-geek his buddies by wishing for an authentic looking alien during a reenactment of their favorite science fiction TV show. The Godparents comply by "borrowing" an actual alien prince, from an actual alien war planet, whose actual alien parents plan to actually blow up the earth if they don't get him back! / Timmy finds a nemesis that makes his school life as miserable as Vicky does his home life - his completely insane teacher, Mr. Crocker. Crocker, a firm believer in the existence of Fairy Godparents, becomes suspicious and demands a parent/teacher conference when Timmy brings an extinct dinosaur to Show and Tell.

Timmy takes a wish too far and ends up alienating himself from his true friends. Cosmo and Wanda shrink Timmy so that he can interact with and enjoy his micro-biology homework.

Timmy wishes himself back in time to stop his dad from winning a trophy. After a big fight with Wanda, Cosmo runs home to live with his mother.

Timmy wants to meet his favorite comic book hero, The Crimson Chin, so he wishes him out of a comic book and into reality -- which is bad. Confronted with the fact that he's nothing more than a fictional character, The Crimson Chin has a crisis of confidence, putting his comic book in peril of cancellation! Timmy attempts to pull the Chin out of his depression by wishing himself into the book and becoming "Cleft, the Boy Chin Wonder." / Timmy gets jealous when he sees how nicely Vicky treats her obnoxious, weenie dog, Doidle and wishes that he and the pooch could switch places. Poof! Timmy's brain and the dog's brain switch bodies!

Timmy wishes for the city mascot's freedom. Timmy wishes everyone in the world to be the same.