Plagued by gambling debts, tax troubles, and a psychotic ex-girlfriend, criminal defense lawyer Keegan Deane (Greg Kinnear) represents a notorious serial killer who’s recanted his confession, threatening to bring down the storied LAPD detective who put him behind bars ten years earlier.

As he’s representing a trio of young Amish men who attacked a church elder, Keegan (Greg Kinnear) uses Scarlet (Necar Zadegan) and Ben’s (John Ortiz) recommitment ceremony to woo an attractive car service driver with a penchant for older men.

While defending a mother with a severe gambling addiction, Keegan (Greg Kinnear) scrambles to make up for causing skateboarding legend Tony Hawk to cancel his appearance at a school fundraiser.

In the wake of his father’s death, Ben (John Ortiz) enlists Keegan Deane (Greg Kinnear) to take over the defense of a prominent Los Angeles city government advisor accused of murder and cannibalism.

Keegan (Greg Kinnear) exploits the judge and prosecutor’s rocky divorce in his defense of a prominent restaurant owner charged with bigamy. As Mikki (Bojana Novakovic) seeks help fending off a vindictive ex-client, personal and professional problems plague Scarlet (Necar Zadegan) and Ben (John Ortiz).

Keegan (Greg Kinnear) and a prosecutor each set out to lose the case of a mother who’s confessed to jury tampering in an effort to overturn her daughter’s murder conviction. Mikki (Bojana Novakovic) asks Keegan not to ruin her romance with a rival lawyer as Maddy (Miranda Otto) tries to end his influence over their teenage son.