Chicago newspaper sportswriter P.J. Franklin's life as a woman living and working in a man's world is challenged when she's attracted to a handsome new colleague in the press box.

P.J. isn't sure what to think after Bobby comes home from a road game bearing gifts, and then shows up at Crowley's Tavern with a beautiful woman on his arm.

As P.J.'s efforts to play matchmaker for Stephanie cause a rift to open up between them, she learns that everyone knows about her and Bobby.

After concluding that they are all in a dating slump, P.J. persuades her friends to take her with them on their night of hunting for women.

As Brendan drops a bombshell about his on-again, off-again girlfriend, P.J.'s "grownup" dates with Hank leave her friends without a ringleader.

As she reluctantly agrees to get to know Brendan's fiancée, P.J. decides that the time has come for her new boyfriend, Hank, to spend some time with her pals, too.