Film students Kaiser Whitman and Charlie Burns follow Dwight Nixon as he shares the story of how his wife, Emily, went missing.

The team look into the disappearance of Sarah Winston, who also went missing on the Howard's Mill property, years before Emily went missing.

The group investigate Wayne Richie, the caretaker of the Howard's Mill property, who has a connection to someone close to the Emily Nixon case.

The group find a third missing person's case and search the Howard's Mill house where they discover a secret about the Howard family.

The team track down the Howard's kid and Glynis recalls the day her parents abandoned her. Meanwhile, Dwight, Kaiser, and Charlie find a secret cave.

Kaiser and Charlie question if the Bell Witch could be the reason why people are going missing. Meanwhile, divers find a body in the bottom of the pond.