Mark and Andy return to their childhood town of Cavendish, Prince Edward Island where a reunion with their estranged father is marred by a peculiar superstition that they dont quite remember.

Mark and Andy are cast in a local theatrical production of Anne of Green Gables but soon find out that they are not prepared for the unusual commitment standards that the director demands of them.

A wax statue of childrens entertainer and musician Fred Penner brings trouble to the Museum. The statue of the Canadian icon drives Andy to the edge of insanity while Mark tries to rescue his brother.

When Mark wants to borrow money, Andy convinces him to get a job. But when Mark takes work in a travelling carnival, he risks getting sucked into a lifestyle from which he may never return.

While in town to see a show, Mark, Andy and Molly get lost after dark in a dangerous Charlottetown neighborhood. Now they must run, hide and fight their way back to the tourist zone before they become victims of big city crime.

Mark convinces Andy to join the local Coven with him to have some fun. But when Andy fits in better than Mark, the latter starts a much more sinister Coven, threatening to ruin Andy's newfound group.