With Reagan (Christina Applegate) working more closely with Luke (guest star Steven Pasquale), Chris (Will Arnett) starts to show signs of jealousy, but it takes his buddy Reed’s (guest star Will Forte) bad advice to send him into a full-blown panic. Meanwhile, Ava (Maya Rudolph) is surprised to learn that her rival will be competing against her in a 10K run for charity and enlists the help of celebrity trainer Gideon Kirk (guest star Fred Armisen). Jennifer Hall also stars.

"The Ava Show" is cancelled - Reagan and Ava's friendship is tested following the news of the show’s cancellation. Meanwhile, Reagan hires her brother Scott to help remodel their bathroom, and Chris decides to re-enter the working world.

As Chris and Scott take on their new business, Reagan tries her best to get the hang of being a stay at home mom and deal with the quirks of the neighborhood. Meanwhile, Ava is unexpectedly reunited with her former accompanist, Walter, whose life she may have ruined on her rise to success.

Reagan and Chris start to worry that they are becoming an ordinary couple and go to great heights to prove otherwise. Meanwhile, Scott helps Ava declutter her life when she encounters her biggest fan.

After Chris runs into his annoying college roommate Jerry, he is roped into attending a party and brings Ava along to keep him sane and hopefully find her a match. Meanwhile, Reagan reluctantly helps Scott throw a raucous sleep over for his son and his friends.

Reagan and Chris realize it has been months since their last night out and decide to paint the town with Ava and Jerry. Meanwhile, on Chris' advice Scott tries his hand at dating again.